The state Senate has narrowly defeated a measure to give parents who send their children to a non-public school an income tax deduction for certain educational expenses – such as fees and textbooks.
It was dubbed the “parent’s choice” bill.
“This bill would incentivize the private sector to take some of the financial burden off the state and local taxpayers by supporting and building more schools,” said Sen. Jessica Unruh (R-Beulah). “This bill alos helps make private education a more viable choice for families of all walks of life, and helps them provide what they feel is best for their children.”
“What this bill will do is acknowledge parental choice in finding the best educational environment for their children,” said Sen. Nichole Poolman (R-Bismarck). “We say we value educational choice. But the reality is – choice is only available to families that can afford it.”
Tioga Republican Senator David Rust says the bill would be a major policy change in funding education in North Dakota.
“It essentially allows, through a back-door maneuver, state dollars going to non-public schools,” said Rust. “Schools that operate on a different set of principles with regard to religion, due process, special needs and a number of other things.”
Sen. Howard Anderson (R-Turtle Lake) said he was concerned about the Constitutionality of a bill concerning the separation of church and state.
“”Just be sure that unintended consequences down the road, that you will be able to defend your religious schools against the state, once they become dependent on tax deductions or some other methods of funding,” said Anderson.
The bill failed on a 22 to 24 vote.
